I think that first, there is no evidence showing that INCLUDING a back squat is to anyone’s detriment. There is a valid question as to whether it is the most effective way to improve squatting strength (paradoxically).

I think I come down in the middle. Certainly if you are banging out back squats religiously to the exclusion of all else, you are more likely to be a problem. And certainly if you have to encase yourself in bandages to do your workout there is already a problem.

But there is a such thing as moderation. There is a such thing as health through variety it seems. If barbell squats are enjoyable for someone, I think that as an adult, they should pay attention to the effect it has on their own body over time, and begin with moderate weight. With that approach, I don’t think we can take the position that barbell squats are inherently bad for everyone.

I agree with you. In training someone the first thing to do is knowing their goals and limit. In some cases, some trainers force their trainees to lift heavy objects more than their limit. It is very dangerous for the heart and muscles.